Utility Week - authoritative, impartial and essential reading for senior people within utilities, regulators and government
Issue link: https://fhpublishing.uberflip.com/i/414726
16 | 14Th - 20Th NovEmbEr 2014 | UTILITY WEEK Policy & Regulation Analysis I t is clear from public comments made in the past few weeks that Ed Davey sees his tenure as secretary of state for energy ending in May at the general election. Fears expressed over "short term populist" policies potentially damaging the sector and calls for continued "cross-party consensus" hardly suggest Davey has "manning the energy helm" scheduled in his diary aer 7 May. In fact, when questioned he went as far as to say it was "likely" he wouldn't be continu- ing. Whether this is because Davey is feeling pessimistic at the chances of still being in the government aer the election – consid- ering his party's current support levels – or because he has loier ambitions to become leader of his party, remains to be seen. So as Davey starts his long farewell to colleagues at the Department of Energy and Climate Change (Decc), who are the likely candidates to step up to the plate? Front Runners Caroline Flint, Labour Unlike Davey, the shadow energy secretary has the role firmly pencilled into her diary for next year. She has already made it clear in her response to the annual energy statement last week that she has no plans to go anywhere other than from shadow secretary for energy to actual energy secretary. In the three years since she stepped into Davey's shadow, Flint has been instrumen- tal in introducing and pedalling Labour's publicly popular price freeze pledge, and has laid out Labour's plans to bring in more competition, transparency and investment into the energy market. She also plans to lead the abolition of Ofgem, replacing it with a new, tougher watchdog, and the creation of an Energy Security Board. With Labour still maintaining a slight lead in the polls, Flint has to be seen as the bookies' favourite to follow Davey, and Labour leader Ed Mili- band, to become the UK energy secretary. Mathew Hancock, Conservatives Hancock is the most sen- ior Tory MP within Decc, and that makes him the most likely candidate from the blue corner of the Com- mons to step up to the role, although this relies on David Cameron remaining in Num- ber 10, leading a Conservative government. Hancock is the current energy and busi- ness minister, having been shuffled in July when his predecessor, Michael Fallon, le for the Ministry of Defence. As minister for business he is responsible for the low- carbon business sector – a pet subject for the minis- ter, who talks more on business than energy – and the UK Green Investment Bank, which provides funding for renewable projects in the UK. He has a history of opposing onshore windfarms – something the Tory top brass will have taken notice of, especially as the party plans to stop any new onshore wind developments. In 2012 Hancock wrote to the prime minister demanding the slashing of subsidies for onshore windfarms, and oppos- ing plans for new turbines in his West Suffolk constituency. "The visual and other impact of the proposed turbines is completely unac- ceptable in this attractive rural corner of Suf- folk," he said. His staunch opposition to onshore wind, coupled with a close relationship to busi- ness, will have won him fans within the Tory party, and may have opened up a path to the Cabinet table. Stephen Lloyd, Liberal Democrats Should Davey choose to turn down the opportunity to continue as energy secretary (assuming such an oppor- tunity manifests itself), the man trailing in his wake for the Liberal Democrats is his private parliamentary secre- tary, Stephen Lloyd. When appointed at Davey's private par- liamentary secretary, Lloyd was enthusias- tic, calling it "a tremendous opportunity" and "a task he welcomed enormously", allowing him to work towards ensuring the coalition remained the greenest government ever. The MP for Eastbourne and Willingdon has a wealth of parliamentary experience under his belt from chairing and vice-chair- ing a number of key all-party parliamentary groups such as those for Citizens Advice and Trading Standards. However, with Labour unlikely to give up a department that will house their flag- ship policies, and the Tories already ruling out a future coalition, Lloyd looks unlikely to move out from Davey's wing, even if he is an avid supporter of the green economy and low-carbon generation. Long shots Peter Lilley, Conservative Rumoured to be a big voice behind the Con- servative's energy policies for their mani- festo, but his climate change scepticism will count against him. Tom Greatrex, Labour Has the background as the current shadow energy minister and past member of the Energy and Climate Change select committee (ECCC), but is only a solid second choice to Caroline Flint. Robert Smith, Liberal Democrats The ECCC member has a wealth of experi- ence in the sector, but with the Lid Dems fac- ing "political annihilation" at the election, the odds of taking up office in Decc remain long. Who will follow Ed Davey? The energy secretary has all but confirmed he won't be at Decc in six months, regardless of the result of the election, so who is likely to fill his shoes? Lucinda Dann runs through the candidates. The good and the bad Bad policy: The Green Deal - Davey conceded take up of the scheme was 'disappoint- ing' Good policy: The UK is one of only nine EU countries currently on track to meet all three of the 2020 EU climate target