Utility Week - authoritative, impartial and essential reading for senior people within utilities, regulators and government
Issue link: https://fhpublishing.uberflip.com/i/394387
10 | 10th - 16th OctOber 2014 | UtILItY WeeK Interview the organisation to all employees in a very clear way, and then setting targets and clear accountability for the achievement of those targets that are related to the vision. I'm delighted to say that in all areas the employees have delivered to that challenge. Four years ago, the workforce had doubts whether the demands and the vision could be achieved, but those doubts quickly dissipated within 12 months because of the improve- ments that employees were able to deliver." It's not all been good news, however. 2014 began in crushing form with UKPN and SSE the worst hit networks during the Christmas storms. Some 20,000 UKPN customers were le without power on Christmas Day. There was a media outcry, inflamed when Scarsella made some well-meaning comments with characteristic straightforwardness to the Mail on Sunday to the effect that, it being Christmas, many staff were on leave, and "could and should have responded to it better". The resulting coverage focused heavily on Scarsella in personal terms, and UKPN, as well as the rest of the industry, took a battering at the subsequent select com- mittee hearing. Looking back, does Scarsella think it was unfair? "No, I don't think it was unfair. As I said at the time, the storm needs to be seen in the right context. There was the worst weather event for probably a decade or more. UKPN, together with the Scottish network, was the worst hit. Our employees, given the time of year, responded brilliantly, but unfortunately the event occurred on Christmas Eve and we had 20,000 custom- ers off over Christmas, and again I apologise for the disruption or inconvenience caused by that. The reality is, if you've got 20,000 customers off over Christmas, then you expect to be made accountable, and we were made accountable." If there was a similar storm this Christmas, what would happen? "If there's a storm at Christmas to the same extent, then clearly it's very likely that a signifi- cant number of customers will lose their power because a storm generally results in damage to our power lines. But I expect we will respond even better than we responded last Christmas, because you always learn from events and the event of last Christmas was the worst event that we had in ten years." He looks up with a smile: "Having said that, I hope it doesn't happen on Christmas Day!" While the storms episode, and the coverage of it, must have been painful, Scarsella is too much of a pro to be bitter – and he seems genuinely to believe such coverage comes with the territory. What, then, of battles with the regulator, whose recent dra determinations for the first cycle of the new RIIO pricing framework came as a nasty surprise for distribution network operators (DNOs)? Ofgem is seeking to slice £1.4 billion from business plans across the industry, with UKPN the worst affected at £600 million – nearly 9 per cent of its planned expenditure. Let's talk about RIIO. He brightens. "The World Cup?" he asks with mock hopefulness (Scarsella has been a football pro, chairman of Soccer Australia and executive member of Fifa in between running utilities). No, not that Rio – the other one. "Ah – I thought so." He settles down to business: "It's disappointing when I look at the changes Ofgem has made in relation to real price effects and also the smart grid benefits. It's even more disappointing on real price effects when you consider that we operate in a region that is the south of England and London, where everybody would agree that costs in this part of the world increase at a rate that is always higher than the average national inflation rate. "Having said that, we are working co- operatively with Ofgem to try to address what I do believe are the changes that may not have been right." Scarsella is hopeful of a constructive agreement with Ofgem on real price effects, which set the expected change in the prices of inputs that DNOs purchase relative to economy-wide inflation, at its final determinations in November. More worryingly, he warns that the high level of savings Ofgem is seeking to claw back on smart grid innovations could discourage networks from innova- tion. "The industry, with the help of the Low Carbon Network Fund, has invested £400-500 million over the period [in innovation], but Ofgem is saying the benefit to consumers over the next eight years on an industry basis is something like £900 million. Now, that's an excellent rate of return for an R&D-type project – in order for the DNOs to benefit they have actually got to deliver benefits from innovation over and above the £900 million. A more equitable outcome would have been for those ben- efits to be shared between consumers and DNOs." Scarsella is more sanguine on the extra savings Ofgem is seeking on the smart meter rollout as part of the overall smart grid savings. Taking a moment to reiterate his support for the rollout, despite some reservations shared by the rest of the network industry on its supplier-led model, he says: "When I looked at the deliverability of the benefits of smart meters from a DNO perspective, it will be a challenge, but I think they will be achievable." Smart meters will be one part of a much wider change in energy consumption that will inevitably see the role of the networks change. "I think it will be a positive change. Today when a customer has their power cut off for whatever reason, we generally wait for the customer to call us to tell us that their power is off. With smart meters, we will know as soon as the power goes off, therefore we will be able to respond a lot more quickly than we do today and that will be for the benefit of consumers. There are big challenges for the DNOs, though." With the increase in distributed generation and the emergence of new business models such as community power, some experts are warning that the traditional distributor model is doomed. Does Scarsella think the networks are agile enough to respond? "They have been able to respond to all sorts of chang- ing demands over the past 30 to 40 years and will be able to respond to the changes that are occurring today." Or, to put it another way, as Scarsella, Kate Bush and the pros at UKPN all know: the show must go on. "When I looked at the deliverability of the benefits of smart meters from a DNO perspective, it will be a challenge, but I think they will be achievable" Keynote speech Basil Scarsella will be delivering a keynote address on "meeting the demand for low carbon technologies" at the Utility Week Congress on 14-15 October. Other speakers include Ofwat chief executive Cathryn Ross, Ofgem chief executive Dermot Nolan and Scottish Power chief executive, retail and generation, Neil Clitheroe. For more information and to book your place, visit: www.uw-congress.net